In the past 6 days since I've been browsing all the Icon sections assiduously, I've noticed a disturbing trend: the download to comment/fave ratio for icons is insanely disproportionate. It's not uncommon to see figures like 2000 downloads, 5 comments, 2 faves.
That means literally thousands of people like the art enough to snag it for themselves, but not enough to express a word of appreciation. Granted, many of those downloaders may be visitors, but I'm sure there are at least hundreds of dA members among them.
I suspect it's the eternal battle between art and artisanship at the heart of this. If you use it, you're less inclined to comment on it as art, less inclined to notice the artist, less inclined to thank him or her for beautifying your daily routine.
So, this is my appeal to all y'all icon lovers out there:
say something! Support the artist, show your love, reject the hoary old distinctions between art for use and art for viewing. You don't have to wax poetic. Even an "Oo! Cool! Using it." would be a vast improvement over the eerie silence that reigns now.
To get a feel for some of the gorgeousness you might have missed out on in the Icons gallery, check out
Skin Deep, an article by ^
abe-x and =
ipholio which showcases customization gems.
Oh, and don't be shy about noting me any suggestions you have for DD's anywhere in the Icons gallery. This is an equal opportunity operation here.
Border emotes courtesy of =brokenboulevard The whole thing courtesy of =Zikes
Devious Comments
I'm still going to attempt to make one of these suckers one day
--
Assistant Director of Artist Relations
This is exactly what i've just ranted on about in my journal!
--
In your search for absolution, there is only one solution... Kick a pigeon in the park!
| ~melonhead118 | `brokenboulevard |
Encouraging comments is a wonderful thing, and I'm glad you pointed out that it's better than nothing. But we should just as strongly encourage critique within the "Icon community" of deviantART.
I had more to say, but I can't remember what it is. I blame ADHD.
--
Каждая хаотической становится гармония.
--
My hexopus love queen avatar product of =sereneworx's talent and generosity.
--
My hexopus love queen avatar product of =sereneworx's talent and generosity.
--
My hexopus love queen avatar product of =sereneworx's talent and generosity.
--
Assistant Director of Artist Relations
I agree with what you are saying... if you like something one should post a comment if you have time. Doesn't necessarily have to be a lengthly one at that.
You're right, though, that the regular denizens of the Icons gallery should seek to provide more detailed, useful feedback. That's what people are here for, after all. I think I'll make another journal entry on critiques. I'm not sure people even know how to do them, frankly. Critique sounds a lot like criticism, even though they aren't the same thing.
Thanks for the thoughtful comment. Talk about practicing what you preach.
--
My hexopus love queen avatar product of =sereneworx's talent and generosity.
Previous Page12345...Next Page