Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?

deviantART

 

Show Your Icon Love!

Journal Entry: Fri Nov 17, 2006, 11:26 AM


In the past 6 days since I've been browsing all the Icon sections assiduously, I've noticed a disturbing trend: the download to comment/fave ratio for icons is insanely disproportionate. It's not uncommon to see figures like 2000 downloads, 5 comments, 2 faves.

That means literally thousands of people like the art enough to snag it for themselves, but not enough to express a word of appreciation. Granted, many of those downloaders may be visitors, but I'm sure there are at least hundreds of dA members among them.

I suspect it's the eternal battle between art and artisanship at the heart of this. If you use it, you're less inclined to comment on it as art, less inclined to notice the artist, less inclined to thank him or her for beautifying your daily routine.

So, this is my appeal to all y'all icon lovers out there: say something! Support the artist, show your love, reject the hoary old distinctions between art for use and art for viewing. You don't have to wax poetic. Even an "Oo! Cool! Using it." would be a vast improvement over the eerie silence that reigns now.

To get a feel for some of the gorgeousness you might have missed out on in the Icons gallery, check out Skin Deep, an article by ^abe-x and =ipholio which showcases customization gems.

Oh, and don't be shy about noting me any suggestions you have for DD's anywhere in the Icons gallery. This is an equal opportunity operation here. :)


Border emotes courtesy of =brokenboulevard
The whole thing courtesy of =Zikes


  • Mood:

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 1 1 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconfallenrox:
:clap:


I'm still going to attempt to make one of these suckers one day :)

--
Assistant Director of Artist Relations
:devart: fallenrox@deviantart.com
:iconmelonhead-emotion:
HOMG! Talk about great minds think alike!

This is exactly what i've just ranted on about in my journal!

--

In your search for absolution, there is only one solution... Kick a pigeon in the park!
| ~melonhead118 | `brokenboulevard |
:iconjoysoftruth:
I'm always excited whenever an emoticon or something else in my gallery starts to rack up views, but when it gets to 100 views, and only one or two comments, and perhaps a favourite or two, I start to feel down. It's very hard to find people on deviantART who are willing to give critique, especially on emotes. Usually it's a comment of, "Oh, that's so cute and small!" rather than a comment of, "I think you should touch up the shading on the left side, it looks too dark" etc..

Encouraging comments is a wonderful thing, and I'm glad you pointed out that it's better than nothing. But we should just as strongly encourage critique within the "Icon community" of deviantART.

I had more to say, but I can't remember what it is. I blame ADHD. :giggle:

--
Каждая хаотической становится гармония.
:iconlivius:
Yes! Please do. I promise I'll comment on it like crazy. :glomp:

--
My hexopus love queen avatar product of =sereneworx's talent and generosity.
:iconlivius:
:highfive:

--
My hexopus love queen avatar product of =sereneworx's talent and generosity.
:iconlivius:
Yeah, our first sentences are twins! :giggle:

--
My hexopus love queen avatar product of =sereneworx's talent and generosity.
:iconfallenrox:
Telling me how bad it sucks! :lmao:

--
Assistant Director of Artist Relations
:devart: fallenrox@deviantart.com
:iconlawrencededark:
Funny how we can talk via emots.

I agree with what you are saying... if you like something one should post a comment if you have time. Doesn't necessarily have to be a lengthly one at that.
:iconlivius:
I think detailed critique in general is actually pretty hard to come by on dA. It takes a fair amount of time and concentration, for one thing, and a lot of people are commenting more as a form of applause than as a critique. I can respect that. It's certainly a positive, supportive impulse, unlike downloading someone's work for use without even bothering to thank the artist. That's truly selfish, and, I believe, an insult to all the effort and talent the artist put into the piece.

You're right, though, that the regular denizens of the Icons gallery should seek to provide more detailed, useful feedback. That's what people are here for, after all. I think I'll make another journal entry on critiques. I'm not sure people even know how to do them, frankly. Critique sounds a lot like criticism, even though they aren't the same thing.

Thanks for the thoughtful comment. Talk about practicing what you preach. :thanks: :hug:

--
My hexopus love queen avatar product of =sereneworx's talent and generosity.

Journal History

Should I extend the Blithering Idiom contest deadline? 

38%
66 deviants said I am so smart. I am so smart. S-M-R-T. I mean S-M-A-R-T.
30%
52 deviants said No. You have enough entries to gag a goat already.
21%
37 deviants said Yes, I could use another 2 weeks (Aug 22).
10%
18 deviants said Yes, I could use another month (Sept 5).
2%
3 deviants said No. I got mine made, so fug everyone else right in the ear.

ShoutBoard

Want to learn how to make emotes?

Want to learn how to make computer icons? Click here to learn how, courtesy of ~gakuseisean.

Want to change your default XP icons? Click here to learn how, courtesy of ~monolistic.

Current Contests


Current Projects


Emote clubs

:iconemotisaurs: :iconemotiverse: :iconthe-emoticon-club: :iconemoclub: :iconemote-universe: :iconsmileyfactory: :iconemoti-con:
Avatar clubs

:iconavatar-inc: :iconavatar-magic:
Icon clubs

:iconiconsclub:
Le stampage

Shoutbox

~mazka:iconmazka:
:( we miss you
Wed Nov 12, 2008, 12:34 AM
`DeMaulwurfn:iconDeMaulwurfn:
:c
Thu Oct 2, 2008, 8:39 AM
~Elizabeth900:iconElizabeth900:
OH MY GOD! >.<
Sun Sep 21, 2008, 4:02 PM
!saragould2:iconsaragould2:
wwhhhooooooooo
Wed Jun 11, 2008, 7:43 PM
~jkcustoms:iconjkcustoms:
HA! Thank you for featuring my project!
Tue Apr 15, 2008, 7:46 AM
~chibi-jak:iconchibi-jak:
bach! :D
Sat Mar 1, 2008, 7:38 PM
~humpy77:iconhumpy77:
:glomp:
Thu Feb 14, 2008, 8:22 AM
~mikahniamhjonas:iconmikahniamhjonas:
Silence is golden, but shouting is fun!
Thu Feb 7, 2008, 2:46 AM
=Abfc:iconAbfc:
We demand a new poll! :#1:
Sat Dec 15, 2007, 12:18 AM
`Solitude12:iconSolitude12:
strange people lurk here >.> Hey liv!!!!
Tue Dec 4, 2007, 8:56 PM

ShoutBoard

Want to learn how to make emotes?

Want to learn how to make computer icons? Click here to learn how, courtesy of ~gakuseisean.

Want to change your default XP icons? Click here to learn how, courtesy of ~monolistic.

Current Contests


Current Projects


Emote clubs

:iconemotisaurs: :iconemotiverse: :iconthe-emoticon-club: :iconemoclub: :iconemote-universe: :iconsmileyfactory: :iconemoti-con:
Avatar clubs

:iconavatar-inc: :iconavatar-magic:
Icon clubs

:iconiconsclub:
Le stampage

Site Map